Why most agencies show you “reach” — and what to ask for instead

If your monthly report opens with reach, impressions and “engagement”, you are being shown the numbers that are easiest to grow — not the ones that pay your bills.

Reach tells you how many people saw an ad. It says nothing about whether any of them bought, called or visited. You can double reach overnight by targeting cheaper, less relevant audiences. The report looks better. Your bank account does not.

The five numbers that matter

  1. Cost per result. Cost per order for an online brand, cost per qualified lead for a service business. This is the price you pay for a customer to raise their hand.
  2. Conversion rate after the click. If people click but do not buy or enquire, the problem is your page or offer — not the ad.
  3. Lead-to-sale rate. For lead generation, how many enquiries become paying customers. Cheap leads that never convert are expensive.
  4. Average order value. A higher order value gives you more room to spend on ads profitably.
  5. True return on ad spend. Revenue from delivered, paid orders divided by ad spend — not the number Meta reports before returns and cancelled COD orders.

What to ask your agency

Ask for one screen, every week, that shows money spent, results bought, cost per result and what changes next week. If an agency cannot give you that, it either does not know the numbers or does not want you to see them.

That is why every Advertorial client gets a Friday scoreboard. One screen. Money in, money out.

Want us to look at your ad account? We will tell you what we would change — in 30 minutes, for free.

Book a free audit
Chat with a founder